It was Christmas, O went to play with the grandparents and we decided to spend a day outlet shopping. (We love outlet shopping and I am still smitten with the super warm winter boots I got. May they never fall apart like all of my shoes do after awhile since I wear them so often.) For the first time since our move to Singapore, we also got to go to a movie theater! Unfortunately, we could only catch daytime showings since we wanted to be back for dinner, and in all of Savannah there were no early screenings of “La La Land”. Darn. (Pip managed to see “La La Land” on some flight somewhere, while I still haven’t seen it!) After perusing our options (I really did not want to see “Manchester by the Sea”), we ended up with the Christmas classic “It’s a wonderful life”.
As you may remember, some of my best film experiences old films were in movie theaters. I still remember how I saw “The General” on DVD at some point and found it lukewarm, while seeing it on a big screen a few years later made me laugh out loud with the audience many times throughout the film. Now I think the movie is amazing, and I am shocked at how differently I perceived the film the second time around. “It’s a wonderful life” did not have an active audience like that, but we sat in one of these cinemas with super large super comfortable reclining chairs – way more comfortable than any couch could ever be – so that was an experience in itself. (By the way, the movie theater was also completely out there in the deepest burbs, and yet the screening was pretty filled with people. Wow.)
It’s a wonderful life
Those of you who know me will know that I love stories that span a lifetime, or at least many years (decades at least). “Huo Zhe” is one of my favorite films because of this aspect, and it’s the main reason why I think “The Magnificent Ambersons” is great. With that said, I still dislike biographies even though they also span a lifetime, probably because biographies always try to paint an actual person’s life (even if it doesn’t aim for complete veracity, because everybody realizes the impossibility of it). I don’t know why that bothers me, maybe because there is a tendency to almost unmotivatedly jump from one big life event to another. Even “Narcos”, which I love, does that.
But I digress. All of these stories ask the question of how a life should be led (which biographies typically don’t). “It’s a wonderful life” does so very actively, even though the story ends up much like a little fairy tale. But even so, there is much to love in this little film, and I can see why it’s a favorite that stood the test of time. (Personally I am a little less sure about “Casablanca”, where the heck did that cult come from that makes a Berlin movie theater show the film every Saturday?!) Pip astutely observed that George Bailey is a great main character because he seems like a generic good guy but he is not perfect: he doubts himself and questions life, and he lashes out on his wife and children in anger.
More interestingly, I agree with this article that the film is an exercise in nostalgia, and that Pottersville is the future while Bedford Falls is a pretty grim version of small town middle class. Instead of feeling all warm and fuzzy, we should be sad that Bailey forsakes his dreams of building high-rises and traveling the world for the conservative values of his father, his little home town and his family, and there is a reason why the internet is full of articles analyzing American society through “It’s a wonderful life”, like this one. But the film surely doesn’t feel like it has any brains at all, instead it completely made me ignore all of it and simply enjoy the heartwarming aspects of the story. (Though personally I think the best part about Pottersville is the nerdy librarian version of the wife. Too cute.)
As a child, I used to love watching those films that were on TV around Christmas, like “The Muppet’s Christmas Carol” (best Christmas film of all times) or “Home Alone” or “Drei Haselnüsse für Aschenbrödel”, and most likely I would feel about this film that way if I had seen it in my youth. But now it was mostly a nice and sweet experience after almost an entire year of not being able to go somewhere with just the two of us.

